Thrillers That Weren’t For Me (But Might Be For You)
Thrillers That Weren’t For Me (But Might Be For You)
Not every thriller book is a bad book. Sometimes it’s just not my thriller book.
I’m picky about thrillers and I’ve realized I have a few “red flags” that will make a story fall flat for me fast. So this isn’t a drag on any author, and I’m not telling you not to read these. These are thrillers that weren’t for me, but they might be for you depending on your thriller taste. If you want a thriller that actually did work for me, here’s my review of The Boyfriend by Freida McFadden.
So if you’re a thriller reader who likes honest opinions (without all the dramatic “worst book ever” energy), here are four popular thrillers that weren’t for me, why they didn’t work, and who I think they might be perfect for.
My Thriller Red Flags
What usually makes a thriller not work for me:
- When it’s marketed as a thriller but reads more like romance or drama
- When the middle gets too messy and loses the main plot
- When characters feel off or the writing choices pull me out
- When the ending doesn’t have enough payoff and I’m left like… “that’s it?”
- When characters of color are written in a way that feels off, unnecessary, or distracting
If any of these don’t bother you, honestly you might have a better time with these than I did. Heads up: this post may include affiliate links. If you click and buy, I may earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you)!
Four Thrillers That Weren’t For Me
1) Verity — Colleen Hoover
Premise
Verity follows a writer who’s hired to finish a bestselling author’s book series after an accident leaves that author unable to continue. But once she enters the author’s home and life, she finds a manuscript full of disturbing “truths,” and things get messy fast.
It wasn’t for me because…
I kept waiting for the suspense to really kick in, but for me this read more like romance/drama with a dark twist than an actual thriller. It didn’t feel suspenseful or intense the way I want thrillers to feel. I wasn’t on the edge of my seat… I was more like “okay so… when are we getting to the THRILL?”
And I’ll be honest, the writing style felt immature in a way that made it hard for me to take the story seriously. I’ve heard people say that’s a thing with some of Colleen Hoover’s books, and I definitely felt it here. It just wasn’t the type of writing voice I enjoy in this genre.
But you might like it if…
You love relationship mess, obsession, shock value, and books that feel like a fast binge-read. If you like thrillers that lean more emotional, dramatic, and scandalous, this might be your kind of chaos.
Also… she’s clearly doing something right because there’s a movie coming and Anne Hathaway is going to KILL it. I’m honestly more excited for the film version than the book.
2) Last Girl Ghosted — Lisa Unger
Premise
This one follows a woman whose online dating experience turns into a mystery when a man she’s been seeing suddenly disappears, and she starts realizing she might not be the only one he’s done this to. It’s a modern thriller with that “something is not adding up” vibe from the start.
It wasn’t for me because…
This one actually started strong. It was well-written, the plot idea was interesting, and it pulled me in fast. But somewhere in the middle, it started getting too in the weeds. The story felt like it was juggling too many directions at once, and it lost some of the focus that made the beginning so gripping.
I also felt like the most interesting part of the story was the angle involving the past girls and their situations, and I wish the book leaned harder into that and what it meant with the characters of the book. That part had the most potential to be intense, haunting, and emotionally heavy. Instead, it felt like the story rushed through pieces that could’ve been more developed, and then suddenly we were at the conclusion.
But you might like it if…
You enjoy modern mysteries, online dating thrillers, missing person stories, and books with a steady slow-burn unraveling. If you like a plot that gets more complicated as it goes, you might love this one.
3) Creep — Jennifer Hillier
Premise
Sheila Tao is a psychology professor who’s engaged, but she ends up in an affair with her graduate teaching assistant, Ethan. When she tries to end it and move on with her life, Ethan does not take rejection well and things spiral into blackmail, obsession, and a nasty cat-and-mouse situation.
It wasn’t for me because…
I tried so hard to like this book because the premise is strong and the thriller angle is definitely there. But I spent most of the book frowning. The story kept pulling me out instead of pulling me in.
And I’m going to say it plainly: I didn’t like how the book wrote characters of color. But to be fair, as little as they were in there at least she tried to put them in versus other authors. Certain choices felt off to me, and once that feeling set in, it kept distracting me from the suspense. So even when the plot was doing what it was supposed to do, I wasn’t enjoying the reading experience. I finished it, but it just wasn’t for me.
But you might like it if…
You like darker thrillers that lean into obsession, control, and “this is getting worse by the page,” and you don’t mind characters making messy decisions that set the whole plot on fire.
4) Every Last Secret — A.R. Torre
Premise
This is a domestic/psychological thriller about two couples in a wealthy neighborhood: Cat and William Winthorpe, and their new neighbors Neena and Matt Ryder. Neena becomes fixated on William and the Winthorpes’ lifestyle, and the story turns into a rivalry between Cat and Neena that escalates into manipulation, secrets, and a lot of calculated behavior.
It wasn’t for me because…
It wasn’t that A.R. Torre cannot write, the writing is strong and the alternating perspectives are one of the best parts of the book. I also liked the way the characters were drawn because you can feel the power struggle.
But the payoff didn’t hit for me. I got to the end like… okay? That’s it? I wanted more suspense and more “thriller” energy. It felt like it was building toward something sharper or more shocking, and then it just kind of… landed. So I walked away disappointed because I could see the potential, but it didn’t deliver the impact I wanted.
But you might like it if…
You like rich-neighborhood drama, messy power dynamics, and psychological tension that’s more about rivalry and control than jump-scare twists.
Final Thoughts
If you loved any of these thrillers, don’t jump me 😂 they just weren’t for me. Everybody’s thriller taste is different, and sometimes a book can be popular as hell and still not hit your personal buttons. These are just the books that weren’t for me, but they might be perfect for you depending on what you like. And if you have a thriller that actually delivered suspense the whole way through and had a real payoff at the end… I need recommendations immediately. I’m always looking for my next “can’t put this down” read.
