Book Review: The Neighbor Favor by Kristina Forest, All The Feels
This post contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. All reviews are my own, and I either purchased the book myself or borrowed it using my Libby library card.
The Neighbor Favor by Kristina Forest is a contemporary romance that delivers all the cozy, slow-burn vibes. Centering on Lily, an aspiring editor, and Nick, a mysterious author, this story begins through anonymous emails and blossoms into an unexpected in-person connection. What starts as a virtual pen pal relationship soon becomes deeper without either of them initially realizing it. It’s giving You’ve Got Mail for the modern reader, but better. With a Black couple at the center, soft moments, and a drama-free romance arc, this book was refreshing and joyful.
Kristina Forest became an auto-read author for me with this one. I picked up the book after seeing it around during her promo tour, and I’ll admit, the gorgeous cover featuring a Black couple drew me in immediately. I was looking for a feel-good romance, and this gave me exactly what I needed. The initial email thread felt cheeky, nostalgic, and sweet, just like a 2000s rom-com.
What made this book resonate with me was its writing style. Kristina’s voice is smooth and familiar in the best way, like a friend telling you a love story. From the song references to the cookout moments, it felt like I was reading something written for me, not just at me. The supporting characters added depth and warmth, too. I didn’t realize this was part of a series with Lily’s sisters, but I plan to read the others once I come down from my thriller phase.
If I had one tiny complaint, it’s that I wanted more from the email exchange. That part of the story pulled me in, and I wish it had lasted just a bit longer. But maybe I was going too fast because I was enjoying it so much.
This is the kind of romance that lets love be soft. No trauma bonding, no heartbreak Olympics, just chemistry, tension, and joy. It made me feel stoned and in love in the best way.
🔥 Lit Meter: 5/5 Lighters
- Readability When High: Super easy to follow, even if you’re a little faded. The writing flows, the pacing is smooth, and the dialogue feels real.
- Mind-Blown Factor: This isn’t a twisty read, but emotionally? The vibes hit hard. Especially if you’re craving soft love stories.
- Vibe Check: Romantic, nostalgic, and just a little cheeky. It’s like slipping into your favorite hoodie and watching a rom-com that gets you.
- Smokability: This is a warm-tea-and-a-hybrid type of book. Something that relaxes your body and lets your heart stay open.
- Would I Reread While Baked? Yes. 100% yes. Especially the email parts. They’re cozy and intimate in a way that feels timeless.
If you’re looking for a romance that gives you joy without dragging you through the mud, The Neighbor Favor should be next on your list. You can grab it here and let yourself fall in love a little.